In our last Perspective article “Creating Real ROI Across Your Retail Network,” we addressed four key categories to consider when planning to optimize a physical network of retail locations. What retail, healthcare and bank brands recognize is that despite disruption, their stores, clinics and branches are still essential gathering spots for consumers. It’s not just their presence that matters; these locations are a place where the brand can really come to life for consumers. It’s no wonder that brick and mortar retail locations still deliver no small amount of business for their brands. In the financial services industry in particular, retail bank branches are still the #1 driver of market share.
It’s this market potential that has banking giants like Chase redoubling their branch efforts to reach 93% of the U.S. population by 2022. While increased market share may be a heady prospect for bank brands, decisions about how to capitalize on branches should be rooted in reality. The goal for any bank brand looking to enhance their branch network is to balance experience with efficiency. With experience in mind, banks want to create a space where people want to talk and transact, depending on each site’s defined purpose. On the efficiency side, banks want to make sure the space is as compact (yet functional) as feasible. In the end, the bank wants to pay out as little as possible for that presence.
However, what some may read into the word “efficiency” is shuttering. In fact over many decades in corporate life, efficiency experts have measured ROI and made recommendations for underperforming retail stores. From the 1980s forward, downsizing and closure has been de rigueur with big brands slashing brick and mortar locations that can’t make the cut. In 2019, retail closures continue apace with 29% more store closings announced than in the entirety of 2018. But banking is different. When we say efficiency, we aren’t generally speaking to a binary existential question: to close or not to close. What we mean instead is a range of options informed by what is known as The Network Effect.
First observed a decade ago, The Network Effect is a phenomenon signifying when a bank has more branches in a concentrated area, that bank earns more market share per branch. When planning networks, one would assume that market share would be a simple 1:1 multiplier. We’d expect a network of five branches that gets $40 million in deposits per branch to get the same or similar per additional branch when it expands to ten locations. What we actually see is that individual branch share increasing with each additional location… so that same institution might acquire up to $55 million per branch. In this example, The Network Effect yields a 1.25 ROI multiplier when they double branches in a concentrated area.
When a bank increases its branch network, it sees all boats rise. What’s at work here is perceived presence. When a consumer sees branches – regardless of size – populated in their local area, they see more ubiquity and are statistically more likely to do business with that bank. These branches are building off of each other, so the more branches in a local area, the more market share each branch will gain. This effect helps bank brands in their decision-making process, knowing that if they have 10 branches planned, it makes more sense to cluster those together in a particular geographic area than to spread them across the state, in order to get the most return on investment.
Nonetheless, that doesn’t mean that bank brands have to make massive investments in their largest, full-format branches to take advantage of The Network Effect. There is a range of form and function available to banks in order to optimize their investment. In our next installment on getting branch network smarter, we will take a look at the best ways to capitalize on that perceived presence, resulting in maximum impact with minimum spend.
To learn more about our market analytics services or request a copy of our upcoming white paper on branch optimization and transformation, contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org.